Monthly Archives: August 2021

How to be critical.

On a recent visit to the Mint Room my friend asked me if I am ever critical of Restaurants and how I deal with that.

My response, based mainly on my experience of reviewing restaurants and bars in Mojacar, Spain was that I don’t usually write about poor experiences.

I’m aware that a small amount of bad press can damage a small restaurant that is struggling to stay afloat.

But that’s a bit grandiose of me. To assume that my Fat Boys breakfast blog is powerful enough to hurt any business assumes it is read by so many people or that it has such authority that it really could influence the prosperity of a venue, is probably far fetched.

What I meant was, I try not to be too critical. I chose my words carefully. I tone down criticism.

At the end of the day food is subjective and what I like others may dislike. I have in the past praised places only to revisit and find they aren’t that good. Do I take responsibility for that?

Do I take credit for sending scores of new customers to a place because I gave it 5 stars? I doubt it.

So my Blog is, I hope, a fair reflection of my views ( at the Mint room last Friday there was 4 of us and my friends had their own views) at that time, on that date of that dish. The next day it could be completely different.

But let’s be honest, I’ve only got a few readers, some of whom live abroad. I’m hardly gonna shake the restaurant world and leave it quaking

I do shorter reviews on Trip Advisor and on Google Reviews. Currently my Google audience has passed one million two hundred thousand views, which is amazing. Here I concentrate exclusively on the food, the venue and the service. In my blog I like to wander further afield. It’s like a Ronnie Corbett sketch meandering through all sorts of unrelated events which eventually come back to the starting point. I like to think anyway!

However, other people’s critique may have a different impact.

I saw this by Jay Rayner and thought it might be interesting to include just so you can see how the big hitters deal with being displeased.

I doubt these same standards would be applied to a greasy spoon but it’s an interesting juxtaposition.

Note his comments about the crab cakes which mirror my views on the Sweet potato Kebabs I ordered as a starter. His come from Findus, mine from Iceland but you get the point.

In the footnote Jay makes reference to restaurants that won’t allow guide dogs ( or Seeing Eye Dogs as Arlo Guthrie calls them) which is a shame because they might have enjoyed my Sweet potato Kebabs ?

Sadly the pictures didn’t copy and paste across so I hope this hasn’t spoilt it for you.

3 Park Lane, London W1K 1QA (020 7629 8888). Starters £16-£42, mains £32-£135, desserts £16-£20, wines from £84

Editors don’t send their journalists to cover wars because they like misery and carnage. They do so because the readers need to know about the carnage. By the same token, albeit with rather less moral urgency, I didn’t go to the pop-up of the Polo Lounge on the rooftop of London’s Dorchester Hotel because I like watching rich people pay ludicrous prices for cack-handed food that’s a gross insult to good taste, manners and commercial decency. I went because some risible hospitality operations need to be called out. Being positive is all well and good, but that shouldn’t mean absolute shockers get a free pass.

The original Polo Lounge, so named because wealthy polo players once frequented it, opened at LA’s Beverly Hills Hotel in 1941. Obviously, nobody now goes for the Italian-accented American bistro food. They go there to be in a Hollywood power room; to eat your shrimp, as I once did, two tables down from Whoopi Goldberg, surrounded by the ghosts of Astaire, Garland and Dietrich. At the London version I got to eat a table away from Alex Salmond. And that was the least troubling aspect of my evening. I had brunch at the original a few years back. It was all perfectly adequate and perfectly overpriced, in a Beverly Hills sort of way, which is where it should remain.

The Dorchester Group is owned by that uber homophobe the Sultan of Brunei, who introduced punishments under sharia law for homosexuality, including the death penalty, until he was forced to back down because of an international outcry. As reviews go that’s pretty damning, but let’s push on. The Beverly Hills Hotel is part of the group, so they’ve transplanted an etiolated version of the Polo Lounge to the rooftop of the mothership on Park Lane, until the end of August. On a hot London evening it’s delightful to be outside, nine floors up with a view over Hyde Park. With all that comes an expectation of greatness, reinforced by the stipulated minimum spend of £60 a head.

The menu tells me they are delighted to bring “a taste of Tinseltown” to London complete with “pink bougainvillaea”. And there it is, climbing the wall behind me. I touch it. The bougainvillaea is plastic. So are the tables, the place mats and various of my fellow diners’ body parts. There’s anatomy on display tonight that hasn’t moved since 2010. The menu promises “live music”. They have a glum-looking DJ, blundering through a soundtrack of club tunes. In the sense that she’s pressing play it is, I suppose, a kind of live, but also deathly.

But look, we’re on the top of the world, so let’s get into it. Bloody hell, look at those prices. The bread basket is £16. The salads start at £28. A bowl of pasta is £38. A steak is £135. Certain items are described as Polo Lounge “signature” dishes. Prime among them is the McCarthy salad, named not after the commie-hunting senator, which would make a certain vindictive sense, but a polo player called Neil. It costs £38, and arrives looking like someone with an organising compulsion has been at the Garfunkel’s salad bar.

There are separate sections for chopped beetroot, skinned tomato, bacon minced to a paste, chicken breast with the texture of value-range cotton wool, cubes of sweaty, squeaky cheese, shredded egg and, on top, an avocado that’s been halfway through an egg slicer. Underneath is shredded romaine, including the gnarly hard bit at the centre. That displays serious commitment to gross profit, in all senses. They offer to toss it table-side. Once it’s been mixed with an over-emulsified, over-sweetened balsamic vinaigrette that looks like congealed gravy, I know where it should be tossed. Then I think of the poor pedestrians nine floors below. The combination of that terrible dressing, smothering over-processed ingredients murders appetite. Incidentally, get that dressing on your napkin and people will think you had gastric issues and couldn’t make it to the loo in time. (Small note: the toilets include bidets; what is that about?)

The three diminutive crab cakes for £32 have a rigid shell the development chefs at Findus would envy and taste only lightly of crab, as if embarrassed about the star ingredient. They come with a sauce reminiscent of school-dinner salad cream circa 1975. A £38 bowl of rigatoni bolognese has a grimly sweet and cloying sauce that tastes mostly of tomato ketchup and profit. It’s the dish an oligarch, who only sees his kids every other weekend, chooses for them. According to the menu these dishes are meant for sharing. I apologise to my companion for doing so. They will also be delivered “as they are prepared to ensure you receive them at their best”. This is their best? Oh.

Perhaps the solution is a drink. I bang on about pricey wine lists and get shouty when the cheapest bottle is over £30. Well, buckle up. The cheapest bottle here is £84 for a bog-standard Bardolino rosé which generally retails for around £13.95. Here it’s six times more expensive. I order the second cheapest, a Terrasses Rosé from Château Pesquie. It’s £90. I find that online for £12.75. That’s a multiple of seven. Almost all the wine list is marked up like this. Somebody sat in a room jack-knifed over their calculator, fingers punching furiously, and thought this was fine. It isn’t fine.

But there are positives and they must be accentuated. There’s a sweet cloud of chilled strawberry soufflé, with a little compote at the bottom, which is a true delight. It’s a £20 delight, but a delight all the same. Then there are the waiters who are all friendly, relaxed and completely on it. I imagine them, on their break, with thousand-yard stares, brooding on a career move. A life in organised crime would certainly be less socially divisive.

A few years ago, my less than positive review of the Parisian gastro palace Le Cinq was dismissed by the management as “rich bashing”. Here, it’s the restaurant that seems to be bashing the rich, flogging them dismal food at inexplicable prices. At the end, a perky waiter asks me how it all was and in my gruesome passive-aggressive way I say, “Fine”. She replies, “Amazing.” I think: “Yeah, let’s go with that.” I have a bill for over £370 for a meal that included a dreadful salad, terrible crab cakes, mediocre pasta, and a grossly overpriced rosé. If that isn’t amazing, I really don’t know what is. 

And there’s more. The blind BBC journalist Sean Dilley took to social media recently to express his huge frustration after he and a friend, who is also blind, were refused entry to two restaurants around London’s Leicester Square because they had their guide dogs with them. This contravenes the Equalities Act 2010 and is therefore unlawful, however can only be challenged through the courts, which is arduous and time consuming, rather than by being reported to the police. That does not relieve restaurants of their legal duty to allow guide dogs into their restaurants. Plus, unlawful or not, it’s the civilised, hospitable and humane thing to do.

But let’s finish with some good news. Recently I reported that the great JoJo’s in Tankerton was crowdfunding to buy the freehold of their building, so the restaurant would survive. They have hit their £100,000 target. JoJo’s lives (jojosrestaurant.co.uk).

Email Jay at jay.rayner@observer.co.uk or follow him on Twitter @jayrayner1

Interestingly I’ve had a reply from the Mint Room which I think is as good as it gets. I tried putting a review on Google but they limit the amount of words you can use so it means you can’t really be accurate.

However, the Mint Room went to my blog and actually Redman the full article. As a result they have suggested there were some lessons to learn.

That isn’t a bad outcome is it?

The Mint Room, Bath.

13/08/21

I had a mate from school who opened a restaurant in Hotwells called The Red Herring and for a few years he made a reasonable living, at least enough to buy a huge 5 storey house at auction.

The house was right on the end of the Portway at the junction with Cumberland Basin.

He got into trouble for painting the end wall red without planning permission as it was a grade 2 listed building. Even worse, it is front and centre in many an iconic picture of the Avon with the Suspension Bridge above so they forced him to repaint it cream.

Like many new restaurants the Red herring’s popularity was short lived and it eventually closed but Pete had seen it coming and built a commercial kitchen in the basement of his house from where he ran a small catering business.

He made ‘Quiches’ and sold them to all the local deli’s in Clifton, Kingsdown and Bedminster where there were lots of artisan shops selling niche items of food.

These Quiches sold like hot cakes and he couldn’t make them fast enough.

One time he told me the secret of their success, it wasn’t the look of them although that helped, it wasn’t his own special pastry casing though that was perfect.

The secret, he told me was. “Dont put any flavour in them”.

When he first started he made his quiches using lots of fresh local ingredients. So his Broccoli Quiche had lots of fresh Broccoli pieces in them as well as Broccoli flavouring.

He couldn’t give them away.

When he took the broccoli out, used food colouring instead and just threw a few bits of stalk into the mix to give a hint of authenticity, he sold them as fast as he could bake them.

It’s a bit like the cakes we bought in Sainsburies a few Christmases ago.They looked fantastic but they didn’t taste great and we threw most of them away in the New Year.

This story came to mind after our visit to the Mint Room, Bath.

Their web site proclaims:

“The Mint Room have built a reputation of providing dishes which are daringly different, high-end, with first-rate British ingredients brought to an enticing level of Indian flair. Emphasizing (badly spelt) the luxurious combinations of flavours with a great sense of innovation that draws upon both traditional and modern Indian cuisine.”

Though I’ve eaten hundreds of Curries in all sorts of venues including, India and Mauritius I had never been to the Mint Room so I was keen to give it a try. It has a reputation for delivering high end Indian dining and the promotional material really hyped it up.

My mate Cary booked a table for 4 on Friday evening at 1830 which was a bit early but it was apparently the only slot they had available.

Our first challenge was to find some where to park as there is no dedicated parking and almost no on street parking anywhere near the restaurant. Luckily I found a space on some waste land at the back and took a chance that I wouldn’t get a fine.

When we arrived at the restaurant the doors were opened for us and we were shown into the reception area. We didn’t know whether or not we should be wearing a mask and the guy that greeted us put one on, but then took it off again which was a bit confusing.

When we gave our names they couldn’t find our booking despite them phoning that morning to confirm our attendance. However, they said there was a spare table and seated us in a booth just next to the reception desk.

Our server introduced himself and provided menu’s for food and a separate one for drinks.

I asked whether the food served was generally considered Hot (as in Spicy) or Mild and I was assured it would all be mild.

The next challenge was to read the menu. The fonts seemed to be in different colours against different backgrounds which might have been alright in good light but it was extremely dark where we were sat and none of us could see what was on offer. So we resorted to using our mobile phones as torches.

The Menu was interesting, It had a good selection of items, but only one page was dedicated to traditional Curries as we have come to expect them in the Bangladeshi restaurants we all know and love.

Sadly the Tasting menu (£39 per person) wasn’t available which was a shame as that would have been a good way to sample a range of dishes that were new to me.

We gamely ploughed on through the menu and after some changes eventually we all decided which option we were going for. And we were ready to order.

I’m not a great lover of ‘Popadoms and Pickles’, they tend to be very bland and you can often get better pickles in a jar from our local Indian shop, but I know other people consider this an essential element of a night out at the Balti.

So we ordered one portion to share (£2.50).

The menu described each dish exquisitely in mouth watering terms and sought to emphasise the locally sourced credentials of the Mint Room.

Jaki went for Rajasthani Lamb Chops. £9.95

Free range Welsh Lamb Chops marinated in Kashmiri Chilli, Yoghurt, Cloves and Cardamon cooked in a clay oven. These looked and tasted delicious.

Rachel chose the Anjeer Paneer Tikka. £7.95

Indian cheese marinated with Green Chilli and Cardamon and Cumin stuffed with Fig and Mint Chutney. This looked a great starter and Rachel seemed to enjoyed it.

Cary had already decided on Tawa Scallops. £10.95.

Pan fried King Scallops marinated with Fennel, Star Anise and Turmeric topped with Roasted Peppers and served with a Tomato relish.

I understood King Scallops came with the Roe where as queen scallops were meat only and were much smaller? These had no Roe and were tiny?

I went for the Shami Kababs or Sweet potato Shami as they are listed on the Menu. £8.95.

Spiced sweet potato patties with Ginger and Sautéed Peppers, Served with Green Coriander Chutney.

I’m sorry to say they were very disappointing. They had very little flavour despite the description on the menu. They could easily have come straight from the freezer at Iceland. They were small tasteless veg patties (which I make at home from left over veg and potato) and I am still at a loss to know what happened to the Green Coriander Chutney?

However, we still had the main course to come.

Jaki went for the Keralan Halibut. £17.95.

A Halibut fillet cooked with Coconut, red chilli and raw Mango tempered with mustard seeds, curry leaves and Broccoli.

It looked a bit strange with a whole stump of Broccoli led on top of a piece of fish. Sadly she wasn’t very impressed with the flavour combinations. The Fish was delicious and meaty but she would have preferred it served with fresh veg and new potatoes rather than the bland tasteless sauce provided.

Cary chose the Chicken Lababdar. £16

Free range Somerset Corn fed chicken supreme cooked in the House Lababdar sauce, with mixed peppers, Coriander and fresh cream. Served with Saffron Rice.

“Lababdar” means a strong desire of something and complete surrender to it. Lababdar as a term is attached to this dish to signify complete surrender of one’s taste buds to that dish.

This seemed like a good choice but Im still not sure what a Lababdar Sauce actually is but I think he enjoyed it ?

Rachel went for the Roasted Raan. £18.95.

Tender slow roasted welsh lamb shank braised for 8 hours in spices and its own juice with Wilted greens and Awadhi style sauce. ‘

Awadhi cuisine is all about slow-cooking, known as dum in India, much of which is done in the tandoor. ‘This brings out amazing flavours and textures, which when combined with the rich, perfumed flavours from the spices create one of the best cuisines in the world. Apparently.

This was a robust dish with a large shank of lamb but it looked very firm given it had been braised for 8 hours. I know in Spain the Slow cooked Lamb falls off the bone as soon as its touched?

Im not sure the sauce that accompanied it was anything like a curry sauce but Rachel seemed to enjoy it though she left rather at lot at the end?

I chose to stick with the vegetarian options and went for Kadai Paneer. £13.00.

Indian Cheese with Sweet Peppers, infused with tangy Tomato and Fenugreek finished with Kashmiri Chilli and crushed roasted Coriander.

Luckily I had asked them to make this hotter (they added some chopped green chilli) or this would have been completely bland. It really had little to recommend it though the actual Paneer was good, the sauce was lacking any character and there was no ‘tangy tomato’ as far as I could tell.

You can just see my choice in the bottom right hand corner of this photo.

We also ordered a Bottle of Veramonte Caramenere (£26.00) a Vegan wine and a glass of Chardonnay (£4.75).

NB: My friends all had trouble with the wine glasses provided which were a strange shape. They found it difficult to drink without its spilling ?

As the driver I rewarded myself with a glass of non alcoholic Ginger beer. Very Famous Five of me.

The restaurant itself was very modern and I was fascinated by the gold textured wall behind the girls but it was just so dark.

We also had to ask for the air conditioning to be turned down as it was way too cold where we were sat though I suspect people had a different view depending where they were sat.

The seating was comfortable and looked rather swish but the booth was a bit big and I had trouble hearing the conversation at the other side of the table, though there wasn’t a lot of back ground noise.

Service was attentive, polite and knowledgeable.

Sadly my food looked good but lacked any taste.

There is clearly a demand for this type of food, particularly some where like Bath where there are lots of visitors happy to part with their hard earned cash. But for me, I prefer my Indian to be a bit more traditional.

I dont need Flock wall paper, Sitar Music playing in the back ground and pictures of Elephants on the wall, but I do like a hot spicy sauce.

Years ago my Mate Raf came to England from Mauritius with his mate Ali. Ali got a Job as a door man at an Indian Restaurant in Corn Street, He had to dress in mock Indian clothing with a Turban and curled shoes. He couldn’t speak much English but told each customer.

“Very Nice, Very Hot, Very Tasty” No matter what they asked him!

The Mint Room delivers a modern take on Indian Cuisine, But Its not an Indian Restaurant and it didn’t work for me.

Like Pete’s quiches, the food looked good but lacked any taste and at these prices, I expected more.

I enjoyed being out, I enjoyed the company but I was underwhelmed with the food.

On the way home we drove through Bath and there were lots of pretty little Bistros with people sat outside on the pavement. The evening was warm and this looked far more appealing than siting in the Mint room with the air con on full.

Next time!

The Upton INN 11/8/21

My Auntie Jan isn’t too well so my Sister Maria and I arranged to pay her a visit and see if we could cheer her up a bit.

Auntie Jan and Uncle Gilb ( I couldn’t say Gilbert as a Kid so I called him ‘Burgit’ for some strange reason) were good to me. I used to stay with them quite often playing with my Cousin Gary who was a few years younger than me but at that age, it didn’t seem to make a lot of difference.

Gary had a huge box of Toy soldiers, not fancy tin ones but plastic and we would tip them out on the carpet in the lounge and spend hours choosing the make up of our army.

“Picks’ it was called. You took it in turns choosing one soldier at a time. The idea would be to get a group of soldiers in the same position, stood up, kneeling, led down. It didn’t seem to matter if they wore different uniforms and we even mixed and matched Cowboys and Indians on horse back with Marines.

Once the armies were lined up opposite one another, battle commenced and we would make the noise of gunfire and randomly knock over a few of the oppositions military to symbolise the damage caused by a volley of shots. Eventually there would only be one man standing (usually mine as I was the oldest and could manipulate the game far more adeptly).

Looking back we must have learnt some skills about negotiating and communicating which would have helped us as we got older. I dont remember Gary ever complaining that i was unfair or that he always seemed to lose the war?

Gary did have some artillery pieces that worked on a spring mechanism and fired a match stick but that took so long to load and was a bit erratic so didn’t do the amount off damage to the lines of soldiers required. We would still be playing now if we only used the cannons.

The other thing i remember about those games was the names we used. Pete and Steve were common. We got them from the Westerns we watched on TV.

Most popular Cowboys (remember Sugar Foot, Cheyenne Bodie, Maverick, Wagon Train, Wells Fargo etc) had mates that were called Steve, Chris or Pete. Never Stewart or Nigel!

We used to have Tea and Biscuits for breakfast. Dunking the biscuits in the tea without them getting so soggy they broke off was an art form.

In earlier days ( before Jan and Gilb had their own family) they lived with my Grand Parents in a big three bed flat in Montague Hill, Bristol, just behind the Bristol Royal Infirmary. They were a very modern attractive young couple. Gilb had been in the army doing his military service and was over 6 foot tall, a bit of a novelty in those days.

He worked as a Docker at Bristol Docks and would set off on foot down to the Docks looking for work most mornings. Invariably he would be home again mid morning if he ‘Bumped’. The Term they used for not getting picked for a days work.

It seems the Gangers would chose a group to work that day and if you were their mate, you got lots of work. If you weren’t, you ‘bumped’.

I remember My Auntie Jan counting the freckles on my nose which was a lovely experience. Her and Gilb bought bubble gum and we had a bubble blowing contest. Some thing My mum would never allow.

When they eventually moved out they got a flat on Marlborough Hill and they bought a vacuum cleaner, the first I had ever seen. Its was so exciting playing with the flexible hose that resembled a large snake.

So it was nice to catch up.

Auntie Jan is the oldest person in our family and is the only one alive now who remembers people and places from a long lost generation of the family. The Hobbs’s, The Pipers and all the uncles and aunties that peppered my early life.

Auntie Nell who was about 4 foot tall and always walked looking down at the ground incase she found a Penny.My Auntie Vi who lived in the Malago area of Bedminster and always looked so Posh but was as poor as a church mouse. As well as many others.

This status will pass to me at some stage. I will be the oldest in the family. What a responsibility?

So after our visit we decided to find some where for lunch.

It not really my side of town (Oldland Common) so I dont know the area too well and it was getting on so lots of the Cafes would be closed at 2pm. We found ourselves driving through Willsbridge toward Bitton and I remembered a Pub i had used quite regularly when i was working for the FBU and decided to head there.

The Upton Inn at Upton Cheyney has always had a reputation for good food and being up a narrow lane it is a sort of Hidden Gem, though it was quite popular on the day we visited.

The lane leading up to the pub from the A431 is very narrow with few passing places so be careful. When we left we went on toward Wick and the road got even worse, much narrower and no places to pass at all. Luckily we reached a wide spot just as a van came the other way.

We asked to be seated outside as it was still warm and sunny and we were shown several options, at the front, back and side of the building. We chose the front by the side of the road as it was the warmest spot though other people were sat in other areas, including inside which looked lovely.

The lady who greeted us returned with the menus. There was the larger menu with a fantastic selection of food options, any one would have suited me, they all sounded delicious. A smaller under stated sandwich menu that punched well above its weight and there was also a selection of specials that she read out. The prices were around £15-20 pop but given you can pay this now in Nando’s I think the prices are reasonable.

I chose the ‘Spicy Chickpea and Nut Burger’ served with Iceberg Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise topped with Onion Marmalade in a Ciabatta Bun with Fries and House Slaw. £15.00 This was a great choice, tasty, filling and very healthy.

Maria went for Chicken Shawarma Salad, a warmed Middle Eastern Chicken Breast
with Quinoa Tabbouleh, Pickled Red Cabbage, Beetroot and Cumin Hummus, Mint Raita and Flatbread £15.50 Hers looked fantastic with all the extra dips and the flat bread and she declared it so good she was determined to finish every last bit, even though she was stuffed.

With a large soda and lime and a great pot of English Tea to finish things off.

The environment was idillic, the service excellent, friendly helpful but not over bearing, food was as good as I’ve had in a long while and the prices were, in my view, reasonable given the quality.

I would recommend giving this one a try. Its a bit off the beaten track but well worth the effort.

Next time we are going to try it for Sunday Lunch. Ill let you know how it goes.