I have been bleating on about seed oils and ultra processed foods for some time now, encouraged by different ‘Experts’ on Social media who claim I’ll seed oils are bad.
I’ve swung back and forward like John Holmes plonker.
But I’ve had to have a rethink lately as my Blood pressure and Cholesterol levels went through the roof.
So I was interested to read this article. From the British Heart Foundation.
Rapeseed oil is a seed oil, like sunflower or corn oil.
It comes from the seeds of a plant from the mustard/cabbage family.
Its flowers are bright yellow and turn fields into a sea of gold when in bloom.
In fact, it has the lowest amount of saturated fat of any oil. It has just half the amount found in olive oil.
Rapeseed oil is also high in healthy unsaturated fats, the type that help lower cholesterol.
It has the second highest level of monounsaturated fats after olive oil. And it has the best balance of omega-3 and omega-6 polyunsaturated fats of all plant oils.
It is grown in the UK and comes in refined and unrefined (often labelled as ‘cold-pressed’) forms.
Refined rapeseed oil has a higher smoke point, so does not lose healthy nutrients when used at high temperatures. This makes it suitable for cooking.
Look on the labels of regular ‘vegetable oil’ and you’ll often find it’s 100 per cent rapeseed oil, so this can be a healthy, cheap option.
Save the more expensive, flavourful cold-pressed varieties for drizzling on salads.
There were concerns in the past about rapeseed oil containing erucic acid, but modern rapeseed oils are almost completely free of it and are safe to use.
Early research also suggested that high intakes of omega-6 could increase inflammation.
However, recent studies show rapeseed’s unique combination of omega-3 and omega-6 is linked to a lower risk of heart and circulatory diseases.
While rapeseed oil can be a healthy addition to your diet, like all oils, it is high in calories, so use it sparingly.
British Heart Foundation Senior Dietitian, Tracy Parker,
Over the last few years I’ve been able to off set this by staying in Spain for the start of winter and though it can get a bit chilly at night and it can rain, the weather is usually ten times better than it is here, which is usually ten times better than it is up North.
Today Mojacar was 17 degrees and clear.
But this year we stayed in Spain in September which was much earlier than we usually visit so it was hotter and very pleasant but it meant we were home for the whole of October and November. A few years ago we came home on the 19th December after driving up through Spain and crossing into France through the Pyrenees.
We managed to get ourselves lost and as it started to get dark we decided to stay in a town called ‘Jaca’.
Typical Bar in Jaca
This was absolutely beautiful, it reminded us of a ski resort, which was somewhat Ironic as it actually was a ski resort and we were lucky to avoid a huge dump of snow that would have trapped us there for several days.
So this is the first year we’ve actually been home for all of the winter, and I’m not liking it.
Its great to have more time with the Kids but they are growing up fast, Blake is now going to pre School 3 days a week so they dont really need us as much.
last week Jaki and I were very busy we, looked after the Grandkids a couple of times, babysat whist Georgia and Frazer took Blake to the cinema and Jaki went out with her sister and her Mum on Wednesday.
I did a few Pilates classes and managed to get a few weight training sessions in.
But despite being busy, by Friday we were both bored.
Its hard to justify as we are extremely lucky but there isn’t anything exciting to look forward to. Guess that’s one of the down sides of being retired.
We dont ever have to get up for work on a cold, wet Monday morning nor do we have the excitement of finishing work on a Friday night and having the whole weekend to look forward to.
Its all a bit Beige.
So I suggested to Jaki that we go out for something to eat Friday evening, just to get us out of the house.
In the past we would have wandered up to the Pub and had a few drinks but I haven’t touched alcohol for over a month and I’m not really inclined to start. The thought of sitting in a pub watching people swallow pint after pint of beer or glass after glass of wine fills me with dread.
So I did a bit of home work and came up with ItalBIn Downend. Though their web site comes with some security warnings which rang a few alarm bells. (Which is why I’ve linked them via Trip advisor site rather than their own web site).
Usually I’m not a big fan of Italian food and in the past we would baulk at the thought of eating Pizza (though we know people who love it) but I am getting better, thanks in the main to some cracking Pizza restaurants we use in Spain.
So initially I thought of the Italian in the High street, Chipping Sodbury which is easy to get to, serves good food and is reasonably priced. But we have been there several times before and I just fancied somewhere different.
I had an image of a quiet little Bistro with a Chianti bottle dripping wax over its string jacket whilst the candle flame flickered romantically on our table. I almost got carried away and heard violin’s and opera so I did a quick reality check.
(There was a great Bistro called the Black Cat in Redland that always had Beef Stroganoff on the menu, Jaki and i Liked it there).
So I Googled Italian restaurants and discovered ItalB which also had some great reviews.
When I phoned they said they could accommodate us at 8 pm , so I booked a table.
However, when it came time to go out into the cold wet night, I would have happily stayed in and watched Gardeners World!
We went through the front door (of the venue) at exactly 8 pm and we could see at once that it was rammed. There was no cosy little table in the corner with a sign saying “reserved for Mr ND and the current Mrs ND”.
In fact there were no vacant seats at all.
It seems we had chosen to visit on the same evening they swiched on the Christmas lights so there were more visitors than usual in Downend and it seemed they all wanted to stuff their faces.
The proprietor was very apologetic and suggested we take a seat in the corridor between the Gents and the Ladies, where we could wait till our table was ready.
We declined this generosity.
Instead we walked across the road to the Horseshoe which was just as busy. It had a real Buzz and felt very Christmassy even though they hadn’t pushed the boat out with their decorations, relying instead on and old Christmas tree with Male pattern baldness.
Looking out the window of the pub.
Jaki had a wine and I had a really nice glass of draught Zero Alcohol lager, which i have to say, tasted like the real thing and cost about the same.
When we returned to the restaurant our table was just being cleared and we were soon seated. Menu’s we’re delivered and the drinks order taken.
Wine for Jaki, Tap Water for me.
We spent some time analysing the menu which had the usual selection of Pizza, Pasta and melted Cheese dishes we have come to expect from an Italian restaurant.
I was tempted by the Chicken dishes but we eat an awful lot of chicken at home and Jaki assured me she could make almost all the dishes on offer if I wanted to try them.
I looked at the Pizza list but couldn’t find one that called out to me so in the end I chose the Penne Arrabbiata £13.95 whilst Jaki went for the Risotto Calabrese £15.50.
Then we waited.
Then we waited some more.
It was now 9 pm and we had booked our table for 8pm so it didn’t seem unreasonable to go up to the counter and ask if some one could take our order `?
Soon after a Lady arrived, apologised for the delay (again) and took the order.
It wasn’t too long ( timing is subjective) till our food came . I had ordered a side of Garlic bread which was delicious if a little on the small side and Jaki had another wine.
The food was good. I really enjoyed mine and I think Jaki enjoyed her’s though her endorsement was only luke warm but what else can you say about boiled rice with a meatball plonked in it?
The restaurant was lively and there was a fair bit of noise.
In my opinion it was a bit too busy.
They had too many people seated (there were just too many tables crammed into the space. Each table was about 2 foot square, to accommodate bigger groups they simply pushed more tables together, so everyone had the same amount of space) and offered too many covers.
Despite the small army of staff on duty the Kitchen just couldn’t cook the food fast enough and this caused the delays.
There were no deserts on the menu but i assume they were available if requested?
However, it was getting late and i was suffering withdraw symptoms from “Im a Celebrity get me out of here” so we asked for the bill and made our exit.
They did bring a free Lemonchello chipito. ( A free drink is usual in Spain at the end of a meal).
The proprietor said farewell to us at the door, apologised once again and thanked us for our patients.
I thoroughly enjoyed our night out.
It was great to see the lights and I was very impressed with the Christmas Tree decorations.
The food was good (if not exceptional) service was professional despite the delays and staff were friendly and attentive.
I really like ItalB and would happily go back again ( It would be a great venue for a lunchtime) but perhaps we will try and find a quieter night to visit?
It was Keiths turn to be ‘Master of Ceremonies” so he picked us up at 0930 on a bright and sunny November morning and drove toward Warmley.
The expectation was high. Was it the ‘Premier Inn’?
The guessing game went on until we pulled up outside of Phat Burgers in Crown Rd, Warmley.
But there the excitement peaked. We were a few minutes early, the place didn’t open until 10am so we waited outside with the guy who “”delivered their daily Bread.”. It was quite a religeous moment.
However, by 20 past ten the place wasn’t open, so we decided not to wait any longer and left the bread man on his own. He had resorted to phoning the number on the board outside, without any luck.
There was some discussion amongst the fat boy about a plan “B” and we eventually settled on “T-Cee’s Cafe, The Kitchen, Station Road Workshops, Bristol, United Kingdom.
Now I’ve used this place a lot in the past. My mate had a warehouse in the complex and I helped out there a few times which meant I got a free Breakfast for my Labours.
I have written about this place in its previous incarnation as Kims Cafe.
See previous Blog. Kims Cafe. 29th June 2016.
But its under new management now so things may well have changed, besides, we didn’t have too many options.
Parking was the first challenge. Although there is a car park at the front and another, bigger one at the rear, there were no spaces, so we drove around for a while till we eventually found a space in front of the warehouses.
Once inside, we chose a table and scanned the large menu on the wall hungrily. There was also a Specials board with some interesting options. In the past I loved their Cottage Pie and Chips.
There were plenty of options but we all settled for the Full English Breakfast.
Two Traditional Breakfasts (£8) including Tea or Coffee plus free refills and two “Big one II” (£9.50) including Tea or Coffee.
Traditional Breakfast isn’t huge
There were plenty of customers already seated, Some were ordering dinner and there was a Buffet set up at the end where a group of people were stood nibbling plates full of food.
Keith did the Honours sorting out the drinks, collecting cutlery and most importantly, paying the bill. When the food came, I got so excited I forgot to take a picture of the Big One so I have had to cut and paste a shot from one of the groups photos. I hope this doesn’t spoil your appetite?
The three Sausages were surprisingly small, catering grade, slightly undercooked and a bit disappointing.
Two eggs were fried nicely and the Yolk’s were ‘Dippy”.
The two slices of Bacon were prosaic as was the generous helping of Baked Beans.
The helping of Mushrooms were reasonable but the large tinned Tomato was very disappointing.
Finally there were two Hash Browns, nice and crisp but they weren’t memorable.
Where was the Black Pudding?
This wasn’t a huge breakfast though it did come with some large slices of White Toast served on a separate plate.
Condiments were on each table contained in a very rustic box but sauce had to be collected from the counter, as did the Sugar which was served up in a small pot by the lady taking the orders.
We ate vigorously and there wasn’t much left at the end though I did note several large Tomatoes escaped our attentions.
The venue is spacious and comfortable. The menu has some great options and most dishes are perfectly acceptable without being remarkable and the prices reflect this.
Well, not actually quick and now I think about it, not really an update.
It’s more a “Spanner in the Works”.
I’ve been doing a bit more research on the “Processed Food” agenda and as such I have been emailing the Dietician at the British Heart foundation who has very kindly responded.
Dear W Hendy,
Thank you for highlighting the articles .
Coconut oil:
We know that diets high in saturated fat are associated with increased levels of bad cholesterol in the blood, and high cholesterol is a risk factor for coronary heart disease and stroke.
There has been speculation that some of the saturated fat present in some oils like coconut oil may be better for us than other saturated fats, but so far there is not enough good-quality research to provide us with a definitive answer. The principal fatty acids within coconut oil, namely lauric, myristic and palmitic acids, consistently raise total cholesterol and LDL-C (Coconut oil – a nutty idea? – Lockyer – 2016 – Nutrition Bulletin – Wiley Online Library)
What we do know is that replacing saturated fats with unsaturated fats like vegetable oil, olive oil and sunflower oil, and their spreads, has been shown as an effective way to help reduce bad cholesterol levels, so this would be a healthier choice. Linoleic acid – the main polyunsaturated fat found in vegetable oil, nuts, and seeds – lowers risk of coronary heart disease.
How stable an oil is when it comes cooking with them is related to their structure. Higher levels of saturation mean that it is more resistant to oxidization, the process where the fatty acids break apart. Butter ,lard ,coconut are highly saturated so are more stable when heated. But from a health perspective, these fats are linked to poorer health outcomes – they can raise blood cholesterol levels, which is associated with an increased risk for heart disease. So the advice for these types of fat remains to consumed them in small amounts.
It’s true that if you heat seed oils, which are high in polyunsaturated fats, to a high temperature and reuse them repeatedly, toxic compounds can build up. However, this is only relevant for restaurants and industrial deep fryers. And there are laws in place to protect the consumers in these cases. Unless you are regularly eating deep-fried foods or reusing or reheating the same oil over several weeks, then there is no need to worry about the health effects of cooking with these oils.
UFP:
You are right, numerous studies have linked ultra-processed foods with poor health including obesity, type 2 diabetes and heart disease. However, the research is still not clear that we need to avoid all ultra-processed foods.
Many ultra-processed foods contain seed oils, but they also have high levels of sugar, salt, and other additives, while lacking fibre and essential nutrients. Therefore, consuming a lot of these foods might be linked to an increased risk of obesity and other health conditions. However, it’s not the seed oils alone that are to blame.
A lot of ultra processed foods can contain seed oils. But they also contain high levels of sugar, salt, and other additives, while lacking fibre and other nutrients. So, eating a lot of ultra-processed foods that contain seed oils might well be linked to an increased risk of obesity and other conditions, but it’s not the seed oils that are to blame.
We recently covered the butter vs margarine debate for Heart Matters and the online version does touch on the issue around the processed nature of butter and margarine. Click here: margarine-vs-butter to read.
Kind regards,
Tracy Parker
Senior Dietitian
British Heart Foundation Greater London House, 180 Hampstead Road London | NW1 7AW DD: 0808 802 1234*
*Phone lines are open Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm.
Now she includes in this reply a link to a very serious article on Coconut oil and if you really have nothing better in your life, you may chose to read it in full here:
The gist of it seems to suggest that Coconut oil is ( unless you buy the expensive one) also processed. As part of the process it seems they dye the fat to make it look pure white., which is a bit of a cheat for a miracle food?
But it seems the main thrust of the article is that Coconut Oil is heavily laden with Fats and can contribute significantly to high Cholesterol levels, particularly the “Bad Cholesterol” LDL.
I give you the conclusions :
Conclusions
Until recently, coconut oil was not commonly consumed as part of the UK diet, with no reported use by any of the participants of the 2008–2009 and 2011–2012 National Diet and Nutrition Survey (PHE 2014). However, the flurry of cookery books dedicated to coconut oil alone, published from 2013 to present, and new products containing coconut oil in the market are likely to have increased our consumption. Coconut oil contains, on average, 90% saturated fatty acids, of which 75% are LDL-C and total cholesterol-raising lauric, myristic and palmitic acids. Such quantities are huge compared to all other food sources (see Figs 1 and 2). The British Heart Foundation and UK Department of Health advise that due to its high saturated fatty acid content, coconut oil should be consumed only in small quantities and that sources of unsaturated fatty acids are a better choice for everyday use (NHS Choices 2015; British Heart Foundation). The Change4Life website (2015) lists coconut oil within a category of foods labelled ‘leave these on the shelf!’. Not only does using coconut oil in place of other fats go against dietary guidelines which recommend reducing intake of saturated fatty acids (DH 1991), but, at nine calories per gram, pure fats are the most calorie-dense food source. Therefore, consuming large amounts of any oil may promote positive energy balance and weight gain.
Unlike olive oil, for example, which is MUFA rich and backed by a large body of evidence supporting its health benefits (Psaltopoulou et al. 2011; Schwingshackl & Hoffmann 2014) as well as a European Food Safety Authority (EFSA)-approved health claim (Agostoni et al. 2011), and rapeseed oil, an omega-3 fatty acid-rich component of the Nordic dietary pattern (Nordic Council of Ministers 2012), there is little evidence to support any health-promoting effects of coconut oil. The effect of coconut oil on CVD risk markers other than plasma lipids is largely unreported in humans, although saturated fatty acids in general have been shown to be deleterious (Vafeiadou et al. 2012; Murphy et al. 2015). Due to existing knowledge regarding saturated fatty acids and heart disease, evidence presented here suggesting that coconut oil raises plasma lipids and a lack of large, well-controlled human studies published in peer-reviewed journals demonstrating clear health benefits of coconut oil, frequent use of coconut oil should not be advised. So, if you spot coconut oil high up the ingredient list, think twice before eating the product on a regular basis.
What I did notice about the article was just how old some of the research was that the article referenced and I did wonder if there were any newer studies that perhaps had a different perspective?
But I am still wrestling with the conflict between foods.
Should I eat low fat spread ( processed) to keep my cholesterol levels ( and my waistline ) down or should I eat healthily ( Butter) and risk a heart attack?
Well Tracy very kindly sent a link addressing that topic too.
However, whether you choose butter or margarine does depend on your own health needs and how healthy your overall diet is. If you have high cholesterol and/or a diet high in saturated fat from other sources, such as fatty meats and processed foods like pastries, cakes and biscuits, then the swap from butter to margarine is a simple and important one to make. If you are lightly buttering your morning toast and the rest of your diet is healthy, then using butter is unlikely to be a problem.
Whatever you choose, all types of fats and oils are high in calories. A tablespoon is over 100 calories, so use them sparingly.
So it seems the jury is still out.
You can chose natural foods like Butter or you can chose ultra processed food like margarine. Both seem to come with some baggage.
Guess we just have to make our own choices?
For my part I think it’s a combination of both, but for now I have moved away from the miracle food formerly known as Coconut oil!
I’m still eating butter rather than spread but there are some healthier spreads than others, so read the labels.
I’ve ditched coconut oil and ghee as a cooking medium and reverted back to extra virgin olive oil ( which we bought for £9 a litre yesterday).
Most of you will know I’ve been trying to eat healthily lately and there is some debate about what ( exactly) I should be eating.
Most people now recognise that our diet is too full of processed food and this is generally accepted as being bad for us. Some food actually contains toxins but I’ll not go into that yet.
The classic example is ‘Spread’.
The advice from Social media suggests a return to butter which is natural and has no additives ( as long as you ignore salt).
But when shopping, things can look like butter without actually being butter. Some blocks of ‘Butter’ actually have oils added so you have to read the label very carefully,
Even harder in Spanish
But I digress.
By eating natural butter I was giving up the ‘ Low Fat spreads’ that had been a staple in my diet for years.
Now, low fat spreads have all sorts of additives in them to make them taste, look and feel like butter but they have to spread straight from the Fridge when cold.
Hence the need for additives.
This ‘ change’ in diet not only added calories to my diet, but increased the LDL ( bad Cholesterol) I consumed and as a result, my LDL level went up to 2.3.
The figure I should be aiming for was 1.8.
So I had to decide whether to stick to the new regime and avoid ultra processed food or return to the low fat regime and accept some of the less healthy options.
Currently I’ve done what I always do, hedged my bets.
We now have butter and spread and I mix and match in the hope that I can ‘cut down’ the bad fats whilst still eating the healthy stuff.
I’ve also changed the way we cook,
I started using Ghee and Coconut Oil to fry with as there was lots of information on line suggesting this was a healthy option. Indeed it might well be but they both have higher LDL content so again, I’ve gone back to using Extra Virgin Olive Oil which is universally accepted as the best option.
(There is an issue about cooking at high temperatures but again, that’s for another day).
I’m hoping I can bring my cholesterol level down without the need for yet more medication.
The solution from my Doctor’s was to reduce the Statin and add yet another tablet. What I would like to do is get rid of the Statin altogether!
I resisted the change in medication because I need to buy holiday (travel) insurance and they do ask if your medication has been changed in the last 6 months.
If the answer is yes, your premium goes up.
There is conflicting advice on line and I have been disappointed by advice on The NHS website which basically tells you to avoid Red meat and Cheese if you want to reduce your Cholesterol but it doesn’t give any guidance on ultra processed food and, crucially , is it better to eat natural cheddar cheese ( high in fat) or processed low fat options?
I took part in the Zoe study during Covid and they now produce regular advice and info about food and health. I get a regular e mail with updates and information.
They regularly produce videos on You tube, some of which are a bit dry and rather boring to watch.
This week there is an article on eating for heart health which as yet I haven’t watched yet.
I also contacted Heart UK and the British Heart Foundation but so far their advice has been less than inspiring,
They have, in my experience at least, trotted out the same old information that can be found anywhere on line,
Stop smoking
Stop drinking ( alcohol)
Lose weight
Take exercise
Eat a healthy diet.
It seems to be the stock response.
One of the big conspiracy theories on line is that the giant Pharma companies and the food industry are in this together,
There is a suggestion that the Tobacco giants got out of Fags and into food and use the same promotional techniques to sell unhealthy food to us.
Then the same firms use their pharmaceutical branch to sell us medicine to repair the damage their food has done.
Win win for the food giants, not so good for us!
When I met the Pharmacist at my GP surgery last week she told me the same.
So I explained to her that I had stopped smoking 50 years ago, haven’t had a drink in 5 weeks, I did 2 Pilates classes and two weight training sessions this week. Lost 10 kilos and I am trying to eat a healthy diet.
Then she told me it was probably genetic so there wasn’t much to be done.
I am apparently a lost cause?
Just received this email from the British heart Foundation. See what I mean?
Many of the seed oils proposed by BHF are processed and some suggest they come with other health issues.
Paid a visit on Saturday morning for the first time since it’s been under new management and there were some teething problems.
This is a very popular venue and a few weeks ago we turned up on a Saturday morning hoping to get breakfast but it was fully booked and they didn’t have any availability till much later in the day. Parking is often difficult and slightly random, but hey they were mostly 4 x 4 ‘s so I guess normal rules don’t apply?
So this time I booked in advance.
When we arrived most tables were taken and the only ones that weren’t had ‘Reserved’ signs on them.
We had a good size table in the window, right next to the wood burning stove which thankfully wasn’t lit. If it had been, we would have been roasted.
As it was there was a draft from the windows that blew under the tables and cut into our legs. The chairs were very solid wooden affairs that were very hard and rather cold on the Bum.
Luckily they had a pile of old blankets ( in need of a wash) so we used a few of them as cushions to sit on.
As there was a queue at the counter we decided to wait for our friends to arrive before ordering. This gave us a chance to look at the menu.
There was a page dedicated to Breakfast options and yet another for ‘other dishes’. There was a selection for kids too as this is a popular place for families. You can see the Gloucester Old Spot Pigs outside, then come in and eat their cousins.
Kids love it apparently?
When our friends arrived I went up to the counter and ordered drinks whilst they looked at the options.
I ordered:
“A pot of Tea for two, a Coffee and a glass of water”.
The water came in a pre filled glass bottle on a help yourself basis but when the Tea arrived, it was one small stainless steel Tea Pot, one cup and a small jug of Milk. I had to go back and explain. They replaced it with a much bigger enamel Tea Pot, two decent mugs and another jug of Milk. (Sugar was in one of those dispensers that you only ever see in Cafes, with a stainless steel spout).
Then I ordered the food.
Three Farm House Breakfasts (£12.50), two with extra Black pudding and one Eggs on Toast with extra Bacon.
Spot the Tomatoes?
By now the place was full and (I think) due to the building originally being a farm building the sound was very loud and metallic, which made it hard to hear the conversation on our table.
When the food came they had sadly forgotten one Breakfast and there was quite a delay till it arrived.
The Breakfast offered:
Two Free Range Eggs (cooked to your liking, so I assume they could have been poached if required) which were nicely done with runny centres and solid whites.
Two slices of ‘thick cut’ bacon that was a bit too well done for my taste but I’m sure some people like their Bacon like this?
A Poplar Farm Sausage (remember those little piggies outside) what ever that meant ?
Two Golden Hash Browns that were deep fried and over cooked.
A round of Granary Toast (white was available) that was plonked on the plate but luckily the butter came separately in a small pot.
A Portobello Mushroom and a pot of luke warm Baked Beans.
Playfully they had hidden the Vine Ripened Tomatoes under the toast!
Such fun.
This wasn’t a big breakfast and I am sorry to say it wasn’t a very impressive breakfast.
It could easily have been but it just failed to meet expectations.
In a ‘Farm Shop’ I expect local quality produce and most of this meal started off in the right place. But the cooking, presentation and service let it down.
Cold beans, over cooked hash browns and (debatably) re heated Bacon isn’t great but forgetting one cover is unforgivable.
An extra £2 for black pudding puts this “Medium size Breakfast” at £14.50 and with a cup of tea, that’s £17 a head.
Sorry guys but I have had much better breakfast for under £10.
However, I wish them well and hope things improve.
Is this your new site? Log in to activate admin features and dismiss this message