Coconut Oil for those with insomnia.

Just a quick update.

Well, not actually quick and now I think about it, not really an update.

It’s more a “Spanner in the Works”.

I’ve been doing a bit more research on the “Processed Food” agenda and as such I have been emailing the Dietician at the British Heart foundation who has very kindly responded.

Dear W Hendy,

Thank you for highlighting  the articles .

Coconut oil:

We know that diets high in saturated fat are associated with increased levels of bad cholesterol in the blood, and high cholesterol is a risk factor for coronary heart disease and stroke.

There has been speculation that some of the saturated fat present in some oils like coconut oil may be better for us than other saturated fats, but so far there is not enough good-quality research to provide us with a definitive answer. The principal fatty acids within coconut oil, namely lauric, myristic and palmitic acids, consistently raise total cholesterol and LDL-C (Coconut oil – a nutty idea? – Lockyer – 2016 – Nutrition Bulletin – Wiley Online Library)

What we do know is that replacing saturated fats  with unsaturated fats like vegetable oil, olive oil and sunflower oil, and their spreads, has been shown as an effective way to help reduce bad cholesterol levels, so this would be a healthier choice. Linoleic acid – the main polyunsaturated fat found in vegetable oil, nuts, and seeds – lowers risk of coronary heart disease.

How stable an oil is when it comes cooking with them is related to their structure. Higher levels of saturation mean that it is more resistant to oxidization, the process where the fatty acids  break apart. Butter ,lard ,coconut are highly saturated so are more stable when heated. But from a health perspective,  these fats are linked to poorer health outcomes   – they can raise blood cholesterol levels, which is associated with an increased risk for heart disease. So the advice for these types of fat  remains  to consumed them in  small amounts.

It’s true that if you heat seed oils, which are  high in polyunsaturated fats, to a high temperature and reuse them repeatedly, toxic compounds can build up. However, this is only relevant for restaurants and industrial deep fryers. And there are laws in place to protect the consumers in these cases. Unless you are regularly eating deep-fried foods or reusing or reheating the same oil over several weeks, then there is no need to worry about the health effects of cooking with these oils. 

UFP:

You are right, numerous  studies have linked ultra-processed foods with poor health including obesity, type 2 diabetes and heart disease. However, the research is still not clear that we need to avoid all ultra-processed foods.

Many ultra-processed foods contain seed oils, but they also have high levels of sugar, salt, and other additives, while lacking fibre and essential nutrients. Therefore, consuming a lot of these foods might be linked to an increased risk of obesity and other health conditions. However, it’s not the seed oils alone that are to blame.

A lot of ultra processed foods can  contain seed oils. But they also contain high levels of sugar, salt, and other additives, while lacking fibre and other nutrients. So, eating a lot of ultra-processed foods that contain seed oils might well be linked to an increased risk of obesity and other conditions, but it’s not the seed oils that are to blame.

We recently covered the butter vs margarine  debate for Heart Matters  and the online version  does touch on the issue around the  processed nature of butter and margarine.   Click here: margarine-vs-butter to read.

Kind regards,

Tracy Parker

Senior Dietitian

British Heart Foundation
Greater London House, 180 Hampstead Road
London | NW1 7AW
DD: 0808 802 1234*

*Phone lines are open Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm.

Now she includes in this reply a link to a very serious article on Coconut oil and if you really have nothing better in your life, you may chose to read it in full here:

https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/nbu.12188?msockid=290665bad62067c0317375e8d743667f#nbu12188-bib-0040

The gist of it seems to suggest that Coconut oil is ( unless you buy the expensive one) also processed. As part of the process it seems they dye the fat to make it look pure white., which is a bit of a cheat for a miracle food?

But it seems the main thrust of the article is that Coconut Oil is heavily laden with Fats and can contribute significantly to high Cholesterol levels, particularly the “Bad Cholesterol” LDL.

I give you the conclusions :

Conclusions

Until recently, coconut oil was not commonly consumed as part of the UK diet, with no reported use by any of the participants of the 2008–2009 and 2011–2012 National Diet and Nutrition Survey (PHE 2014). However, the flurry of cookery books dedicated to coconut oil alone, published from 2013 to present, and new products containing coconut oil in the market are likely to have increased our consumption. Coconut oil contains, on average, 90% saturated fatty acids, of which 75% are LDL-C and total cholesterol-raising lauric, myristic and palmitic acids. Such quantities are huge compared to all other food sources (see Figs 1 and 2). The British Heart Foundation and UK Department of Health advise that due to its high saturated fatty acid content, coconut oil should be consumed only in small quantities and that sources of unsaturated fatty acids are a better choice for everyday use (NHS Choices 2015; British Heart Foundation). The Change4Life website (2015) lists coconut oil within a category of foods labelled ‘leave these on the shelf!’. Not only does using coconut oil in place of other fats go against dietary guidelines which recommend reducing intake of saturated fatty acids (DH 1991), but, at nine calories per gram, pure fats are the most calorie-dense food source. Therefore, consuming large amounts of any oil may promote positive energy balance and weight gain.

Unlike olive oil, for example, which is MUFA rich and backed by a large body of evidence supporting its health benefits (Psaltopoulou et al. 2011; Schwingshackl & Hoffmann 2014) as well as a European Food Safety Authority (EFSA)-approved health claim (Agostoni et al. 2011), and rapeseed oil, an omega-3 fatty acid-rich component of the Nordic dietary pattern (Nordic Council of Ministers 2012), there is little evidence to support any health-promoting effects of coconut oil. The effect of coconut oil on CVD risk markers other than plasma lipids is largely unreported in humans, although saturated fatty acids in general have been shown to be deleterious (Vafeiadou et al. 2012; Murphy et al. 2015). Due to existing knowledge regarding saturated fatty acids and heart disease, evidence presented here suggesting that coconut oil raises plasma lipids and a lack of large, well-controlled human studies published in peer-reviewed journals demonstrating clear health benefits of coconut oil, frequent use of coconut oil should not be advised. So, if you spot coconut oil high up the ingredient list, think twice before eating the product on a regular basis.

What I did notice about the article was just how old some of the research was that the article referenced and I did wonder if there were any newer studies that perhaps had a different perspective?

But I am still wrestling with the conflict between foods.

Should I eat low fat spread ( processed) to keep my cholesterol levels ( and my waistline ) down or should I eat healthily ( Butter) and risk a heart attack?

Well Tracy very kindly sent a link addressing that topic too.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/nutrition/ask-the-expert/margarine-vs-butter

What’s interesting is the suggestion that Butter is a processed food because it is produced from milk/ cream by churning and adding salt.

The article does concede that margarine is an “Ultra Processed food” and there is then yet another link explaining what ultra processed foods are.

https://www.bhf.org.uk/informationsupport/heart-matters-magazine/news/behind-the-headlines/ultra-processed-foods

However, whether you choose butter or margarine does depend on your own health needs and how healthy your overall diet is. If you have high cholesterol and/or a diet high in saturated fat from other sources, such as fatty meats and processed foods like pastries, cakes and biscuits, then the swap from butter to margarine is a simple and important one to make. If you are lightly buttering your morning toast and the rest of your diet is healthy, then using butter is unlikely to be a problem.

Whatever you choose, all types of fats and oils are high in calories. A tablespoon is over 100 calories, so use them sparingly.

So it seems the jury is still out.

You can chose natural foods like Butter or you can chose ultra processed food like margarine. Both seem to come with some baggage.

Guess we just have to make our own choices?

For my part I think it’s a combination of both, but for now I have moved away from the miracle food formerly known as Coconut oil!

I’m still eating butter rather than spread but there are some healthier spreads than others, so read the labels.

I’ve ditched coconut oil and ghee as a cooking medium and reverted back to extra virgin olive oil ( which we bought for £9 a litre yesterday).

Will it make a difference?

Only time will tell.

Leave a Reply